skip to main content skip to footer


One of the better Rueben sandwiches in the area.
Justa Guy via - Jul 27, 2021
This place had great breakfast service was not too quick but that is also because many other baseball teams ate around the same time.
John D'Amico via - Jul 24, 2021
We love coming to Nicks! Havent had a bad meal yet.
Jacquie Turner via - Jul 20, 2021
Man that was an absolutely fantastic breakfast! I'm a big guy and I like a big meal when I go out for a breakfast! Nick's did not disappoint.
Aaron Piazzola via - Jul 18, 2021
Enjoying my pizza and eggplant rollatini after polite and attentive service!
Jackie Parry via - Jul 15, 2021
Great place to eat at , dine in & take out . The food is amazing and the service and the staff are great and very friendly. Their Menu has so many tasty options from breakfast food, to burgers, pasta ,wings , salad , appetizers, pasta dishes , deserts and many other options. Very Clean and family friendly . We have gotten take out an ... read more
Tab Terrano via - Jul 12, 2021
Great breakfast. Andrew was our server and he did a great job.
Julie Marshall via - Jul 7, 2021
The best Eggs Benedict ever ... read more
Nancy Kahane via - Jul 6, 2021
This place was so awesome! Their food is beyond excellent, their portion size is incredibly a lot, prices are very reasonable, clean, outdoor seating and very friendly staff! Loved it!
Sherri Graeff (Cher) via - Jul 5, 2021
Great food & very clean!!!!
terryann hollywood via - Jul 2, 2021
Amazing! Our server was great as well.
Joann R. via - Jun 28, 2021
Great food, here! Excellent Italian food and pizza, which is surprising for a diner. Awesome breakfasts, lunches and dinners!
Anne Marie via - Jun 28, 2021
Awesome local spot. Food was great. Service was great. The manager Andrew was an awesome guy to have a conversation with over breakfast.
Kris Taylor via - Jun 28, 2021
Stopped in twice after Cooperstown All-Star Village baseball games, both times did not disappoint. Awesome pizza, disco fries, breakfast served all day and good pie. Must stop diner.
john bright via - Jun 26, 2021
Food is good, but could be better. Seems a little pricey for what you get. However, Cooperstown is a tourist town in the summer and every place pricey, but the amount of food at other places balances our the cost a little better.
sc c via - Jun 25, 2021
Five of us all had different plates and it was all delicious. Nick's Salad, Delmonico Steak, Pasta Garlic and Olive oil and Meatball sub. Definitely will go back again. Great server.
Lorraine Obergefell via - Jun 24, 2021
Good food great service. And quiet at 8:30 on a Wednesday.
diane james via - Jun 17, 2021
Great service and amazing food! The burgers are the bomb-diggity!
Bob Jong via - Jun 11, 2021
One of our new favorite spots when we visit the area. Great service and awesome food.
Georgette Walters via - Jun 10, 2021
We absolutely loved eating here!! Our waiter was Awesome and the food was Fabulous!! We ate the Hungry Man Breakfast (mine was with pancakes which were HUGE and Delicious and my husband had French toast with his and he Loved them). Our son had the poboy sandwich with shrimp, homemade chips, and a pickle. He said it was delicious and ... read more
Kathy Coleman via - May 23, 2021
Very friendly staff ... read more
Faith Feraudo via - May 22, 2021
Food has been really good orderd a couple times the last 2 weeks the burger was on point and the pizza was good to good delivery time as well ... read more
Snick3rs0519 via - May 19, 2021
The question I have is why there isn't a line outside to get into to this place. Small hiding gem. No matter what you are in the menu absolute delicious.
Olga Perez via - May 12, 2021
Food has improved and the pizza isn't half bad delivery isn't overly long ... read more
Snick3rs0519 via - May 9, 2021
Excellent. My first time here. Great food friendly people huge menu super clean. I recommend comming here..
Barry Murdock via - May 1, 2021
Was our first time. Very impressed with how clean it was. The staff was very attentive. The food was excellent. Had the Reuben and it was great. corn ... read more
Ernie Varga via - Apr 29, 2021
Very good food, friendly staff. Big portion sizes, you definitely get your money’s worth! Would come again.
Brianna Everle via - Apr 28, 2021
Good is always hot amd fresh ... read more
Pinko AE via - Apr 25, 2021
Was happy to get a phone call directly about my misplaced order and offer to make it up.
Sad Fuzz Studio via - Apr 19, 2021
Awesome food friendly staff ... read more
Robert Lamoree via - Apr 17, 2021
Very good ... read more
Renay Gibson via - Apr 11, 2021
Our family loves Nick’s. We have never had a bad meal there. I absolutely love their pizza. They are generally the only place I go for pizza when I am in the area.
Jacki Williams via - Apr 6, 2021
Kinda rude over the phone, asked for a size on the pizza and they said i was asking to many questions and handed the phone off to someone else who was equally as annoyed. Foods good though!
Chris Cincotta via - Mar 25, 2021
Best food big portions and awesome service ... read more
phil francisco via - Mar 15, 2021
Excellent service. Good food!
marie via - Mar 7, 2021
A bit disorganized, but very good food.
Craig Raymond via - Feb 21, 2021
Wonderful food, great service and wonderful staff...very clean as well...
Hope and Brett Winne via - Jan 31, 2021
Just perfect ... read more
Chris Kelley via - Jan 30, 2021
Italian. But so much more! They've got subs, sandwiches, pizza, pasta, entrees and salads. Top tier are the garbage wings, which is Nick's mix of hot, mild, garlic, and bbq sauce. It's delicious, you can thank me later.
Dean Ward via - Jan 20, 2021
I've always been a Pondos fan, especially their garlic wings! Their pizza is also delicious! After adding Nicks Diner, their new restaurant located in town, I don't visit Pondos much anymore as Nick's is closer. However, both restaurants are very clean and comfy with amazing staff and best of all, Nick's has the same menu choices and ... read more
Kate Alexis via - Jan 19, 2021
Reminds me of pizza from home!!! Definitely gonna be our new go to spot for pizza, and we are excited to explore the rest if your menu!! Thanks for the delicious dinner!!
julie ann Bennett via - Jan 17, 2021
Food was great .just had to wait ... read more
Ken Tiff Tiff via - Jan 10, 2021
I came here yesterday afternoon after getting out of a work meeting at Hartwick College. I decided to walk here because I wanted to reward myself with it. It was my first time here. I forgot to leave a review so I'm making it now. I was trying to do it on the Facebook page, but it doesn't seem to allow that option. The server I had ... read more
Ryan Culver via - Jan 8, 2021
When traveling I love to eat local food. Wife saw this place on the map and thought why not. Yelp only gave it 2.5 stars. We were pleasantly surprised and would recommend to anyone. Andrew was on point and homemade food (yes I said homemade) was spot on. Great atmosphere just make sure you bring an appetite cause you won’t leave hun ... read more
Justin Thompson via - Dec 24, 2020
Great selection for Breakfeast.
Righteous Riders via - Dec 20, 2020
Great pizza, great food, attentive owner. Been going here quite a while and always satisfied. Recently had an unfortunate situation with a delivery that took very long. Owner called me at home and made an offer to compensate for the experience. Quality food and looking out for customers= good business. Happy to have Nick's in th ... read more
Brendan Coyle via - Dec 19, 2020
We've been here for breakfast a few times...great biscuits and gravy!!!! We finally went for dinner and it was amazing too!!! One of our favorite spots!!!
Stephani Ross via - Dec 15, 2020
Food was pretty good. We ordered breakfast.
Ian A via - Dec 9, 2020
We ordered online, but we messed up and they fixed our order no issues. Everything came out better than expected. Definitely will give them our business again.
John Keto via - Dec 4, 2020
Andrew is a great server, always makes you feel welcome and talks with you, thanks Andrew, and my breakfast was delicious ... read more
Lynn Cardillo via - Dec 2, 2020
Great Food and Great Service ... read more
Vicky Lawrence via - Nov 20, 2020
I give this spot two thumbs up. I look forward to a return visit. Not close to my job, I wish it was.
Kathy Riddle via - Nov 9, 2020
Great experience and food.
Jack Fauth via - Nov 5, 2020
The best tapioca pudding!
Annie W via - Nov 1, 2020
Service was good, food portions are a little over the top. A lot of food for the money. If you walk away hungry, its your own fault!
William Copeland via - Oct 29, 2020
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire